In the Media - No One Available to Take Your Call? Why Businesses Are Losing Potential Customers

Andy Cullwick, our head of marketing, discusses why law firms are losing potential clients: 

As many as one in five new enquiries to law firms do not get a response, according to research for our latest white paper. It’s a surprising and somewhat shocking statistic when you consider the significant sums that many firms spend on marketing to attract prospective clients. 

Given the fall in claims volumes, you would also expect them to be better at capturing and converting leads rather than seemingly letting them slip through their fingers. Of course, our research only spoke to a representative sample of firms and was focused on personal injury and wills, but we know that it’s likely to be a similar story across not just other areas of law but other sectors too. 

So, what else did our research show? Why is this happening and what are the consequences of ignoring customers?  

For our white paper ‘From First Impressions to Follow-up Calls: Creating a Customer Journey’, we commissioned customer experience specialists’ insights to conduct a mystery shopping exercise of 50 personal injury and 50 probate practices, both online and over the phone. 

The good news was that the majority of shoppers described their interactions with firms as warm, engaging and jargon-free. 

However, it found few were consistently achieving the gold standard of returning calls within fifteen minutes of the enquiry and some were taking hours or days to respond, if at all. A whopping 20% of wills enquiries were completely ignored and while personal injury shoppers fared better with phone calls, 16% of those who emailed or filled in a web enquiry form heard nothing back. 

This study also uncovered significant discrepancies in the way that different departments handle incoming enquiries. For example, 77% of those with a PI enquiry via the web received a call from a fee earner compared to 46% of wills shoppers. PI shoppers were three times as likely to receive a follow-up call within five days. 

First4Lawyers carried out a similar exercise among personal injury firms five years ago and comparison does show that most are a lot better at following up with potential clients once they have spoken. However, that counts for nothing if the initial conversation never takes place.

Why are firms ignoring customers? 

It is a curious one and I don’t think anyone is ignoring prospective clients on purpose. More likely it’s down to a failure in the systems and processes the firms have, or don’t have, in place. 

The difference in response rates between different practice areas, for example, indicates that firms are letting individual departments decide how they deal with incoming enquiries, which makes little sense. Management should ensure a consistent approach. You’re only as strong as your weakest link and when it comes to referrals a personal injury client will expect the same level of service from colleagues in each department. 

Interestingly, one audience member at the recent personal injury futures conference, where I presented our white paper, suggested that some firms may be ignoring enquiries deliberately due to lack of resources, because they thought they were coming from time wasters or because they simply weren’t viable. 

There is merit in this suggestion but, if true, it is a somewhat short-sighted approach. Cherry picking what look like the strongest enquiries is bound to result in some good ones being missed, and it’s not just those that you don’t respond to who are left with a poor impression of your firm, it’s everyone else they speak to. People love to talk about a bad experience far more than they do a good one and that’s the kind of word-of-mouth that no business needs. Far better to invest a few minutes of your time in listening and, if you aren’t able to help, leaving them with a positive impression by trying to signpost them to someone or somewhere who can. 

What needs to change? 

This white paper identifies three key areas where firms should be focusing their efforts. This includes consistent customer service frameworks that cover the whole business and user experience technology. 

The latter sounds fancy, but it really doesn’t have to be, it’s more about going back to basics and mapping out how a potential client interacts with your business. You map out the touchpoints; phone calls, websites, social media etc. and then create user journeys for each type of client to help you identify what happens when and what you may be missing. 

Last but certainly not least are review and comparison websites, which law firms traditionally aren’t fans of, but are commonplace in insurance. With nine out of ten consumers saying they use these sites in their day-to-day life as the quickest and most effective way of getting a good deal, they are becoming increasingly hard to ignore. 

There is a misconception that any such website for the legal industry will be little more than a ‘race to the bottom’ on price, but research tells us that consumers also want to know about experience, speed of service, success rates and reviews. 

A trusted comparison website that offers information on all those five drivers in one place will be a win-win for all involved. 


It seems you are using an outdated browser.

This will impair your browsing experience around the web. Please visit one of the links below to update to a modern browser then re-open the site with the new browser.

Thank you


Can't find what you are looking for?

We are open as normal during the Coronavirus lockdown and are able to help with all your legal needs.

Call us free of charge

0800 567 7866

Request a Callback

Continue browsing